Silicone Pump vs. Electric Pump: Which Is Right for You?

Welcome, new mothers! Congratulations on your journey into motherhood. It is an exciting and sometimes overwhelming time, filled with many choices, including how to best nourish your baby.

Choosing between a silicone pump and an electric pump can be daunting. Both offer convenience and efficiency, but which one is right for you?

This guide aims to help you decide which breast pump suits your needs, ensuring your breastfeeding journey is smooth and comfortable.

Understanding Breast Pumps

Breast pumps are essential tools for many breastfeeding mothers. They allow you to express milk efficiently, ensuring your baby has access to breast milk even when you’re not around.

There are several types of breast pumps, including manual, silicone, and electric pumps. Today, we will focus on silicone and electric pumps.

What is a Silicone Pump?

A silicone pump is a manual breast pump made from soft, flexible silicone. It works through gentle suction, drawing milk from the breast without the need for electricity or batteries.

How a Silicone Pump Works

To use a silicone breast pump, you simply place it over your breast, squeeze the base to create suction, and let it do its magic. The natural suction extracts milk effortlessly.

Benefits of Silicone Breast Pumps

Silicone pumps offer several advantages:

  • Portability: Lightweight and easy to carry, making it perfect for on-the-go moms.
  • Ease of Use: Simple design with no complicated parts or assembly.
  • Affordability: Generally more cost-effective compared to electric pumps.

Ideal For

Silicone pumps are ideal for:

  • Stay-at-home moms: Perfect for occasional pumping.
  • Moms on a budget: Affordable and effective.
  • Traveling moms: Compact and portable, fitting easily into a diaper bag.

What is an Electric Pump?

An electric breast pump is a device powered by electricity or batteries, designed to automate the milk expression process, providing a hands-free experience.

How an Electric Pump Works

Electric pumps use a motor to create suction, mimicking the baby’s sucking pattern. You can adjust the suction strength and speed to suit your comfort and milk flow.

Benefits of Electric Breast Pumps

Electric pumps offer numerous benefits:

  • Efficiency: Extracts more milk in less time.
  • Speed: Faster than manual pumping.
  • Customization Options: Adjustable settings for comfort and milk flow optimization.

Ideal For

Electric pumps are ideal for:

  • Working moms: Efficient for frequent pumping.
  • Moms with high milk supply: Handles higher volumes quickly.
  • Long-term pumpers: Perfect for those planning to pump regularly.

Silicone Pump vs. Electric Pump

Comparison Chart

Factor Silicone Pump Electric Pump
Cost Affordable More expensive
Ease of Use Simple, manual operation Requires setup, more complex
Portability Highly portable, no need for power Less portable, requires power source
Efficiency Slower, manual operation Fast, automated operation

Factors to Consider When Choosing


Your lifestyle plays a significant role in your choice. Working moms might prefer the efficiency of electric pumps, while stay-at-home moms might find silicone pumps sufficient.


Budget is a crucial factor. Silicone pumps are budget-friendly, whereas electric pumps are an investment but offer more features.

Breastfeeding Goals

Consider your breastfeeding goals. Short-term pumpers may find silicone pumps adequate, while long-term pumpers might benefit more from electric pumps.

Comfort and Convenience

Comfort and convenience are paramount. Choose a pump that feels comfortable to use and fits seamlessly into your daily routine.

Expert Insights and Tips

Lactation consultants often recommend trying both types to see which one suits you best. They highlight the importance of comfort and efficiency in maintaining milk supply.

Common Questions

Q: Is a silicone pump as effective as an electric pump?
A: It depends on your needs. Silicone pumps are great for occasional use, while electric pumps are better for frequent, efficient pumping.

Q: Can I use a silicone pump on the go?
A: Yes, silicone pumps are highly portable and convenient for travel.

Usage Tips

  • Silicone Pump: Ensure a good seal on your breast for optimal suction.
  • Electric Pump: Start with a low suction setting and gradually increase for comfort.

Making the Final Decision

Reflect on your specific needs and lifestyle. What are your pumping goals, and how frequently do you plan to pump?

Use this checklist to guide your decision:

  • Frequency of use
  • Budget
  • Portability needs
  • Comfort preferences

Pigeon’s Recommendation

At Pigeon, we offer top-rated silicone and electric breast pumps designed to cater to all mothers’ needs. Our products ensure comfort and efficiency, supporting you in your breastfeeding journey.


Choosing between a silicone pump and an electrical pump depends on your lifestyle, budget, and breastfeeding goals. Both have their unique benefits and can significantly enhance your breastfeeding experience.

Remember, whatever choice you make, you’re doing an amazing job. Happy pumping!